Angelic Arbiter

As of Aug 4, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Angelic Arbiter is $3.78 (M11 #4), and the most expensive is $6.58 (M11 #4, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $3.78, up 0.5% over 7 days, down 7.8% over 30 days, down 4.3% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $5.02 (2026).

Angelic Arbiter has 4 tracked printings across 4 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes.

M11 #4

$3.78

CK $4.49 / $1.35 64%

MP $2.77 61 avail

CMD #5

$4.29 +13%

CK $4.99 / $2.25 48%

MP $3.38 22 avail

JMP #86

$5.02 +33%

CK $4.99 / $2.00 60%

MP $3.11 34 avail

CMA #4

$6.01 +59%

CK $3.99 / $1.80 70%

MP $3.15 21 avail

M11 #4 Foil

$6.58 +74%

CK $4.99 / $1.75 73%

MP $2.60 17 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $2.25 cash for CMD #5; the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 55% (wide).

• Aug 15, 2010 Angelic Arbiter's last ability applies if an opponent attacked with at least one creature during the current turn.
• Aug 15, 2010 During an opponent's turn, that opponent may either cast spells or attack with creatures, but not both (assuming that Angelic Arbiter is on the battlefield for the entirety of that turn). The player may perform other actions, such as activating abilities and playing lands.
• Aug 15, 2010 During your turn, Angelic Arbiter's abilities have no effect on the game.
• Aug 15, 2010 If Angelic Arbiter enters during an opponent's turn, its abilities take actions that player performed earlier in the turn into account, even though it wasn't on the battlefield at the time. For example, if an opponent casts a spell, then you use Leyline of Anticipation's ability to cast Angelic Arbiter as though it had flash, that player won't be able to attack with creatures that turn.
• Aug 15, 2010 If Angelic Arbiter leaves the battlefield during an opponent's turn, its abilities cease to affect the game. For example, if an opponent casts Doom Blade to destroy Angelic Arbiter, that player may then attack with creatures.

Angelic Arbiter has been reprinted 5 times.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment
JMP #86	2020-07-17	Rare	Standard
CMA #4	2017-06-09	Rare	Standard
CMD #5	2011-06-17	Rare	Standard
M11 #4	2010-07-16	Rare	Standard
M11 #4	2010-07-16	Rare	Standard

Angelic Arbiter is the #5,024 most-played card on EDHREC, down 59 places over the last 30 days.