Crippling Fear

As of Aug 9, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Crippling Fear is $0.35 (KHM #82), and the most expensive is $4.49 (PKHM #82p, Promo Pack, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $0.35, down 10.3% over 7 days, down 23.9% over 30 days, down 18.6% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $2.87 (2026).

Crippling Fear has 8 tracked printings across 6 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes, including extended art, promo pack and prerelease treatments.

KHM #82

$0.35

CK $1.29 / $0.17 51%

MP $0.34 111 avail

SCD #72

$0.41 +17%

CK $1.29 / $0.33 20%

MP $0.36 39 avail

PW24 #17

$0.46 +31%

CK $1.49 / $0.38 17%

MP $0.51 40 avail

CLB #745

$0.54 +54%

CK $1.49 / $0.38 30%

MP $0.50 53 avail

PW24 #17 Foil

$0.95 +171%

CK $0.99 / $0.10 89%

MP $0.80 20 avail

KHM #350 Extended Art Foil

$0.99 +183%

CK $2.49 / $0.63 36%

MP $0.71 23 avail

KHM #350 Extended Art

$1.40 +300%

CK $1.79 / $0.45 68%

MP $1.14 24 avail

PKHM #82s Prerelease Foil

$1.49 +326%

CK $2.49 / $1.25 16%

MP $1.43 4 avail

PKHM #82p Promo Pack

$1.52 +334%

CK $1.49 / $0.60 61%

MP $1.42 3 avail

CMM #862

$3.21 +817%

CK $1.49 / $0.38 88%

MP $0.70 60 avail

KHM #82 Foil

$3.29 +840%

CK $1.49 / $0.45 86%

MP $0.69 29 avail

PKHM #82p Promo Pack Foil

$4.49 +1183%

CK $4.49 / $1.80 60%

MP $2.13 4 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $1.80 cash for PKHM #82p (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 60% (wide).

• Feb 5, 2021 Crippling Fear affects only creatures that aren't of the chosen type that are on the battlefield as it resolves. It won't affect creatures that enter the battlefield later in the turn, regardless of creature type. If a creature changes creature types later in the turn, Crippling Fear won't start or stop affecting that creature.
• Feb 5, 2021 You choose the creature type as Crippling Fear resolves, and then creatures not of that type get -3/-3. Once Crippling Fear starts to resolve, players can't respond to the choice or take any actions until Crippling Fear finishes resolving.
• Feb 5, 2021 You must choose an existing creature type, such as Fish or Artificer. You can't choose card types (e.g., artifact) or supertypes (e.g., snow).

Crippling Fear has been reprinted 12 times.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment
PW24 #17	2024-01-01	Rare	Standard
PW24 #17	2024-01-01	Rare	Standard
CMM #862	2023-08-04	Rare	Standard
SCD #72	2022-12-02	Rare	Standard
CLB #745	2022-06-10	Rare	Standard
KHM #82	2021-02-05	Rare	Standard
KHM #82	2021-02-05	Rare	Standard
PKHM #82s	2021-02-05	Rare	Prerelease
PKHM #82p	2021-02-05	Rare	Promo Pack
PKHM #82p	2021-02-05	Rare	Promo Pack

Showing the 10 most recent of 12 printings.

Crippling Fear is the #1,978 most-played card on EDHREC, down 33 places over the last 30 days.