Eerie Ultimatum

As of Aug 8, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Eerie Ultimatum is $2.03 (SLC #5, Borderless), and the most expensive is $16.79 (SLC #32, Borderless, Halo Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $2.32, up 1.3% over 7 days, down 16.6% over 30 days, up 5.5% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $6.16 (2024).

Eerie Ultimatum has 8 tracked printings across 5 sets, in halo foil, nonfoil and foil finishes, including borderless, promo pack, prerelease and extended art treatments.

SLC #5 Borderless

$2.03

CK $3.99 / $1.50 26%

MP $2.28 49 avail

SLC #5 Borderless Foil

$2.30 +13%

CK $3.99 / $1.50 35%

MP $2.46 18 avail

PLST #IKO-184

$2.32 +14%

CK $4.49 / $2.05 12%

MP $3.01 20 avail

IKO #184

$3.14 +55%

CK $4.49 / $1.80 43%

MP $2.47 99 avail

PIKO #184p Promo Pack

$4.33 +113%

CK $5.99 / $2.50 42%

MP $3.94 8 avail

IKO #184 Foil

$4.86 +139%

CK $4.99 / $2.00 59%

MP $3.31 39 avail

PIKO #184s Prerelease Foil

$5.21 +157%

CK $5.49 / $1.85 64%

MP $5.41 3 avail

PIKO #184p Promo Pack Foil

$5.49 +170%

CK $4.99 / $2.25 59%

MP $5.21 3 avail

IKO #332 Extended Art

$5.90 +191%

CK $6.49 / $1.40 76%

MP $3.78 36 avail

SPG #104 Borderless

$6.25 +208%

CK $9.49 / $4.80 23%

MP $5.15 35 avail

IKO #332 Extended Art Foil

$8.20 +304%

CK $9.99 / $4.00 51%

MP $6.83 22 avail

SPG #104 Borderless Foil

$13.25 +553%

CK $17.99 / $9.00 32%

MP $9.21 22 avail

SLC #32 Borderless Halo Foil

$16.79 +727%

CK $13.99 / $5.75 66%

MP $17.60 9 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $9.00 cash for SPG #104 (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 50% (wide).

• Apr 4, 2025 An Aura being put onto the battlefield this way can’t enchant anything else that is being put onto the battlefield at the same time.
• Apr 4, 2025 If an Aura is put onto the battlefield without being cast, the Aura’s controller-to-be chooses what it will enchant as it enters the battlefield. An Aura put onto the battlefield this way doesn’t target anything (so it could be attached to an opponent’s permanent with hexproof, for example), but the Aura’s enchant ability restricts what it can be attached to. If the Aura can’t legally be attached to anything, it remains in its current zone.
• Apr 4, 2025 You choose which permanent cards to return while Eerie Ultimatum is resolving. No player may take actions between the time you choose and the time those cards return to the battlefield.
• Apr 4, 2025 You may choose to return just one permanent card, regardless of its name.

Eerie Ultimatum has been reprinted 13 times.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment
SPG #104	2024-08-02	Mythic	Borderless
SPG #104	2024-08-02	Mythic	Borderless
SLC #32	2022-11-01	Rare	Borderless
SLC #5	2022-11-01	Rare	Borderless
SLC #5	2022-11-01	Rare	Borderless
PLST #IKO-184	2022-04-29	Rare	Standard
PIKO #184s	2020-04-24	Rare	Prerelease
IKO #184	2020-04-24	Rare	Standard
PIKO #184p	2020-04-24	Rare	Promo Pack
PIKO #184p	2020-04-24	Rare	Promo Pack

Showing the 10 most recent of 13 printings.

Eerie Ultimatum is the #1,501 most-played card on EDHREC, down 20 places over the last 30 days.