Generous Gift

As of Aug 8, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Generous Gift is $0.69 (MSC #133), and the most expensive is $64.44 (SLD #369, Borderless, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $1.03, up 45.1% over 7 days, up 5.1% over 30 days, up 110.2% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $2.77 (2026).

Generous Gift has 20 tracked printings across 16 sets, in nonfoil, surge foil, foil and etched finishes, including borderless, alt art and extended art treatments.

MSC #133

$0.69

CK $1.49 / $0.30 57%

MP $0.64 151 avail

SCD #23

$0.95 +38%

CK $1.99 / $0.25 74%

MP $0.90 85 avail

PLST #MH1-11

$1.03 +49%

CK $1.49 / $0.19 82%

MP $0.54 46 avail

CMM #624 Borderless

$1.04 +51%

CK $1.79 / $0.36 65%

MP $0.87 213 avail

CMR #375

$1.04 +51%

CK $1.49 / $0.60 42%

MP $0.95 51 avail

MH1 #11

$1.48 +114%

CK $1.79 / $0.90 39%

MP $0.80 218 avail

CMR #620 Extended Art Foil

$1.49 +116%

CK $3.49 / $1.40 6%

MP $1.64 14 avail

NEC #84

$1.51 +119%

CK $1.79 / $0.90 40%

MP $1.09 81 avail

ONC #70

$1.52 +120%

CK $2.49 / $1.15 24%

MP $1.04 89 avail

DMC #100

$1.55 +125%

CK $2.29 / $0.60 61%

MP $1.26 37 avail

CMM #26

$1.58 +129%

CK $1.99 / $0.40 75%

MP $0.93 243 avail

LCC #128

$1.62 +135%

CK $1.79 / $0.23 86%

MP $1.22 161 avail

NCC #201

$1.62 +135%

CK $1.99 / $0.25 85%

MP $1.22 24 avail

MOC #187

$1.68 +143%

CK $1.79 / $0.23 86%

MP $1.19 71 avail

WOC #68

$1.70 +146%

CK $1.49 / $0.38 78%

MP $1.18 70 avail

CMM #26 Foil

$1.88 +172%

CK $1.99 / $0.50 73%

MP $1.07 39 avail

BLC #106

$1.94 +181%

CK $2.29 / $1.05 46%

MP $1.02 292 avail

CMR #620 Extended Art

$2.00 +190%

CK $1.79 / $0.45 78%

MP $1.51 17 avail

MH1 #11 Foil

$2.00 +190%

CK $2.99 / $0.90 55%

MP $2.07 3 avail

CMM #624 Borderless Foil

$2.09 +203%

CK $2.49 / $0.63 70%

MP $1.04 67 avail

H1R #2 Alt Art Etched

$2.35 +241%

CK $2.99 / $1.35 43%

MP $2.50 5 avail

SLD #2088 Borderless

$2.82 +309%

CK $3.99 / $1.50 47%

MP $2.39 17 avail

H1R #2 Alt Art Foil

$3.29 +377%

CK $4.49 / $1.80 45%

MP $2.50 9 avail

SLD #2534 Borderless Foil

$4.39 +536%

CK $6.49 / $3.95 10%

MP $4.37 12 avail

SLD #2534 Borderless

$5.23 +658%

CK $6.49 / $3.25 38%

MP $4.15 20 avail

SLD #369 Borderless

$42.06 +5996%

CK $32.99 / $20.50 51%

MP $45.58 3 avail

SLD #369 Borderless Foil

$64.44 +9239%

CK $64.99 / $30.00 53%

MP $73.76 3 avail

MSC #133 Surge Foil

CK $2.49 / $0.63

MP $0.69 17 avail

SLD #2088 Borderless Foil

CK $3.99 / $1.00

MP $1.83 15 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $30.00 cash for SLD #369 (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 54% (wide).

• Jun 14, 2019 If the target permanent is an illegal target by the time Generous Gift tries to resolve, the spell doesn't resolve. No player creates an Elephant. If the target is legal but not destroyed (most likely because it has indestructible), its controller does create an Elephant.

Generous Gift has been reprinted 27 times. The Bloomburrow Commander reprint cut the price 26% in 30 days.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment	Price before	Day 1	30 days	90 days
BLC #106	2024-08-02	Uncommon	Standard	$0.74	$0.47	$0.55	$0.85
LCC #128	2023-11-17	Uncommon	Standard	—	—	—	$0.40
WOC #68	2023-09-08	Uncommon	Standard	—	—	—	—
CMM #624	2023-08-04	Common	Borderless	—	—	—	—
CMM #624	2023-08-04	Common	Borderless	—	—	—	—
CMM #26	2023-08-04	Common	Standard	—	—	—	—
CMM #26	2023-08-04	Common	Standard	—	—	—	—
MOC #187	2023-04-21	Uncommon	Standard	—	—	—	—
ONC #70	2023-02-10	Uncommon	Standard	—	—	—	—
SCD #23	2022-12-02	Uncommon	Standard	—	—	—	—

Showing the 10 most recent of 27 printings.

Generous Gift is the #59 most-played card on EDHREC, down 1 place over the last 30 days.

• RANKED 20 Power-Crept Commander Staples to Reconsider