Shoot the Sheriff

As of Aug 8, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Shoot the Sheriff is $0.44 (OTJ #106), and the most expensive is $4.18 (SLP #43, Borderless, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $2.43, up 452.3% over 7 days, up 176.1% over 30 days, up 440.0% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $3.61 (2026).

Shoot the Sheriff has 3 tracked printings across 3 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes, including borderless treatments.

OTJ #106

$0.44

CK $0.69 / $0.07 84%

MP $0.15 481 avail

OTJ #106 Foil

$0.53 +20%

CK $0.99 / $0.15 72%

MP $0.21 109 avail

SLP #43 Borderless

$1.00 +127%

CK $1.29 / $0.26 74%

MP $0.78 143 avail

SLD #7166 Borderless Foil

$2.34 +432%

CK $3.49 / $0.65 72%

MP $1.41 23 avail

SLD #7166 Borderless

$2.43 +452%

CK $2.49 / $0.40 84%

MP $1.30 11 avail

SLP #43 Borderless Foil

$4.18 +850%

CK $2.99 / $0.50 88%

MP $3.56 54 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $0.65 cash for SLD #7166 (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 81% (wide).

• Apr 12, 2024 A card, spell, or permanent is an outlaw if it has the Assassin, Mercenary, Pirate, Rogue, or Warlock creature type. It doesn’t matter if it has more than one of those creature types; as long as it has at least one, it’s an outlaw.
• Apr 12, 2024 If an ability refers to an outlaw or whether a player controls an outlaw, it’s referring only to permanents with one or more of the creature types specified above. Notably, it’s not referring to any spell or card not on the battlefield. However, other abilities may refer to an “outlaw spell” or “outlaw card” in a zone other than the battlefield. Those abilities refer to spells and cards with one or more of the specified creature types.
• Apr 12, 2024 Outlaw is not a creature type. If an effect asks you to choose a creature type, you can’t choose outlaw.
• Apr 12, 2024 The only deputy in the Outlaws of Thunder Junction release is a Mercenary, so no, you cannot shoot the deputy.

Shoot the Sheriff has been reprinted 4 times. The Outlaws of Thunder Junction reprint cut the price 54% in 30 days.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment	Price before	Day 1	30 days	90 days
SLP #43	2025-08-02	Rare	Borderless	—	$11.49	$6.53	$0.95
SLP #43	2025-08-02	Rare	Borderless	—	—	$19.99	$12.94
OTJ #106	2024-04-19	Uncommon	Standard	$0.28	$0.15	$0.13	$0.09
OTJ #106	2024-04-19	Uncommon	Standard	$0.28	$0.32	$0.32	$0.20

Shoot the Sheriff is the #4,162 most-played card on EDHREC, up 2 places over the last 30 days.