Stuffy Doll

As of Aug 8, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Stuffy Doll is $5.37 (TSR #274), and the most expensive is $23.55 (SLD #880, Borderless, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $18.32, up 242.4% over 7 days, up 0.4% over 30 days, up 248.3% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $18.34 (2026).

Stuffy Doll has 5 tracked printings across 5 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes, including borderless treatments.

TSR #274

$5.37

CK $6.49 / $1.40 74%

MP $5.15 80 avail

M13 #218

$5.99 +12%

CK $6.99 / $3.50 42%

MP $5.05 55 avail

CLB #875

$6.06 +13%

CK $6.49 / $3.70 39%

MP $5.61 57 avail

TSP #264

$8.89 +66%

CK $6.99 / $4.25 52%

MP $5.52 31 avail

TSR #274 Foil

$8.99 +67%

CK $10.99 / $5.50 39%

MP $7.25 5 avail

M13 #218 Foil

$13.52 +152%

CK $12.99 / $6.50 52%

MP $7.39 10 avail

SLD #880 Borderless

$18.32 +241%

CK $24.99 / $11.50 37%

MP $17.99 12 avail

TSP #264 Foil

$21.02 +291%

CK $29.99 / $18.00 14%

MP $13.06 4 avail

SLD #880 Borderless Foil

$23.55 +339%

CK $22.99 / $14.50 38%

MP $20.24 20 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $18.00 cash for TSP #264 (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 40% (normal).

• Mar 19, 2021 A creature can be dealt an amount of damage greater than its toughness. For example, if Stuffy Doll is dealt 3 damage, its triggered ability deals 3 damage, not 1, to the chosen player.
• Mar 19, 2021 If your life total is brought to 0 or less at the same time that Stuffy Doll is dealt damage, you lose the game before its triggered ability goes on the stack.

Stuffy Doll has been reprinted 9 times.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment
CLB #875	2022-06-10	Rare	Standard
SLD #880	2021-06-21	Rare	Borderless
SLD #880	2021-06-21	Rare	Borderless
TSR #274	2021-03-19	Rare	Standard
TSR #274	2021-03-19	Rare	Standard
M13 #218	2012-07-13	Rare	Standard
M13 #218	2012-07-13	Rare	Standard
TSP #264	2006-10-06	Rare	Standard
TSP #264	2006-10-06	Rare	Standard

Stuffy Doll is the #2,246 most-played card on EDHREC, up 2 places over the last 30 days.