Subtlety

As of Aug 7, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Subtlety is $12.55 (MH2 #67), and the most expensive is $851.77 (SLD #7005, Borderless, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $12.55, down 19.8% over 7 days, down 15.0% over 30 days, up 11.0% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $15.69 (2026).

Subtlety has 7 tracked printings across 5 sets, in foil, nonfoil and textured foil finishes, including borderless, alt art and prerelease treatments.

MH2 #67

$12.55

CK $15.99 / $6.50 48%

MP $11.99 82 avail

MH2 #67 Foil

$14.00 +12%

CK $22.99 / $11.50 18%

MP $25.52 7 avail

SPG #45 Borderless

$15.37 +22%

CK $22.99 / $10.50 32%

MP $14.84 35 avail

H2R #6 Alt Art

$15.81 +26%

CK $18.99 / $7.75 51%

MP $15.63 7 avail

PMH2 #67s Prerelease Foil

$16.74 +33%

CK $29.99 / $16.50 1%

MP $25.84 6 avail

MH2 #309 Borderless

$17.61 +40%

CK $18.99 / $7.75 56%

MP $15.60 25 avail

SPG #45 Borderless Foil

$23.45 +87%

CK $24.99 / $10.00 57%

MP $19.25 6 avail

MH2 #309 Borderless Foil

$30.38 +142%

CK $37.99 / $15.20 50%

MP $25.26 9 avail

H2R #6 Alt Art Foil

$30.93 +146%

CK $32.99 / $13.20 57%

MP $33.83 7 avail

SPG #50 Borderless Textured Foil

$43.32 +245%

CK $44.99 / $18.00 58%

MP $47.64 6 avail

SLD #7005 Borderless Foil

$851.77 +6687%

CK $1,199.99 / $785.00 8%

MP $1,198.30 3 avail

Card Kingdom currently pays $785.00 cash for SLD #7005 (Foil); the retail-buylist spread on that printing is 35% (normal).

• Jun 18, 2021 A spell that's put into its owner's library doesn't resolve, but it isn't countered. This will work on spells that say they can't be countered.
• Jun 18, 2021 If you pay the evoke cost, you can have the creature's own triggered ability resolve before the evoke triggered ability. You can cast spells after that ability resolves but before you have to sacrifice the creature.
• Jun 18, 2021 Subtlety's triggered ability targets a spell on the stack. It can't target creatures or planeswalkers on the battlefield.
• Jun 18, 2021 The owner of the spell is the one who chooses whether it goes on the top or bottom of their library. All players will know this information.
• Jun 18, 2021 To determine the total cost of a spell, start with the mana cost or alternative cost you're paying (such as an evoke cost), add any cost increases, then apply any cost reductions. The mana value of the spell is determined by only its mana cost, no matter what the total cost to cast that spell was.

Subtlety has been reprinted 11 times. The Modern Horizons 2 Timeshifts reprint cut the price 87% in 30 days.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment	Price before	Day 1	30 days	90 days
SPG #45	2024-08-02	Mythic	Borderless	$15.75	$16.65	$18.43	$11.30
SPG #50	2024-08-02	Mythic	Borderless	$22.87	$22.44	$25.58	$23.30
SPG #45	2024-08-02	Mythic	Borderless	$14.14	$15.04	$16.67	$10.76
H2R #6	2024-06-07	Mythic	Alt Art	—	$26.25	$11.12	$15.11
H2R #6	2024-06-07	Mythic	Alt Art	$116.06	$65.63	$14.98	$19.03
SLD #7005	2021-06-21	Mythic	Borderless	—	—	—	—
MH2 #309	2021-06-18	Mythic	Borderless	—	—	—	—
MH2 #309	2021-06-18	Mythic	Borderless	—	—	—	—
MH2 #67	2021-06-18	Mythic	Standard	—	—	—	—
MH2 #67	2021-06-18	Mythic	Standard	—	—	—	—

Showing the 10 most recent of 11 printings.

Subtlety is the #4,327 most-played card on EDHREC, up 16 places over the last 30 days.