Thalia, Heretic Cathar

As of Jul 23, 2026, the cheapest tracked printing of Thalia, Heretic Cathar is $1.22 (INR #351), and the most expensive is $7.82 (SLC #2016, Borderless, Foil). The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $1.22, down 6.2% over 7 days, up 43.5% over 30 days, up 19.6% over 90 days. All-time tracked high: $4.97 (2026).

Thalia, Heretic Cathar has 8 tracked printings across 5 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes, including borderless, buy-a-box promo and prerelease treatments.

INR #351

$1.22

CK $1.99 / $0.80 34%

INR #351 Foil

$1.41 +16%

CK $1.99 / $0.60 57%

EMN #46

$1.74 +43%

CK $2.49 / $1.15 34%

INR #300 Borderless

$2.17 +78%

CK $2.79 / $0.95 56%

INR #44 Foil

$2.29 +88%

CK $2.49

INR #44

$2.39 +96%

CK $2.29 / $0.80 67%

INR #300 Borderless Foil

$2.85 +134%

CK $2.99 / $0.75 74%

PEMN #46 Buy-a-Box Promo Foil

$3.36 +175%

CK $2.29 / $0.80 76%

EMN #46 Foil

$4.57 +275%

CK $3.99 / $1.60 65%

SLC #2016 Borderless

$4.66 +282%

CK $5.49 / $2.30 51%

SLD #1428 Borderless

$5.01 +311%

CK — / $4.50 10%

PEMN #46s Prerelease Foil

$5.33 +337%

CK — / $3.50 34%

SLC #2016 Borderless Foil

$7.82 +541%

CK $5.49 / $2.30 71%

SLD #1428 Borderless Foil

CK $6.99 / $4.25

Card Kingdom currently pays $4.50 cash for SLD #1428.

• Jul 13, 2016 If Thalia enters the battlefield at the same time as an opponent’s creatures or nonbasic lands, those creatures and lands aren’t affected by Thalia’s last ability.
• Jul 13, 2016 If an effect states that a creature or land enters the battlefield tapped unless a condition is met, Thalia’s last ability has it enter tapped even if that condition is true. For example, your opponent may reveal a Plains while playing Port Town (from the Shadows over Innistrad set), but Port Town will still enter tapped.

Thalia, Heretic Cathar has been reprinted 14 times. The Innistrad Remastered reprint cut the price 97% in 30 days.

Set	Date	Rarity	Treatment	Price before	Day 1	30 days	90 days
INR #44	2025-01-24	Rare	Standard	$2.94	$0.76	$0.54	$1.12
INR #300	2025-01-24	Rare	Borderless	$22.19	$0.71	$0.74	$0.94
INR #351	2025-01-24	Rare	Standard	—	$0.49	$0.28	$0.37
INR #300	2025-01-24	Rare	Borderless	—	$1.14	$1.02	$1.32
INR #44	2025-01-24	Rare	Standard	$7.00	$0.86	$0.64	$0.83
INR #351	2025-01-24	Rare	Standard	—	$13.80	$0.48	$0.76
SLC #2016	2022-11-01	Rare	Borderless	—	—	—	—
SLC #2016	2022-11-01	Rare	Borderless	—	—	—	—
SLD #1428	2021-06-21	Rare	Borderless	—	—	—	—
SLD #1428	2021-06-21	Rare	Borderless	—	—	—	—
PEMN #46s	2016-07-22	Rare	Prerelease	—	—	—	—
EMN #46	2016-07-22	Rare	Standard	—	—	—	—

Showing the 12 most recent of 14 printings.

Thalia, Heretic Cathar is the #1,468 most-played card on EDHREC, down 29 places over the last 30 days.