Magic

Prices updated

Elspeth's Nightmare The List MTG card
PLST #THB-91 · Art by Jason Rainville
PLST set symbol, UncommonThe List#THB-91Uncommon

Elspeth's Nightmare

Enchantment · Saga
Nonfoil
TCGplayer market · PLST #THB-91 nonfoil
$0.11 0.0% $0.00, 7 days
1-year range
30 days
0.0%
EDHREC rank
#12,412 Down 185 in 30 days
Best buylist

Buy PLST #THB-91 nonfoil

Affiliate links. TCG Strat may earn a commission from TCGplayer, Mana Pool and eBay. Prices are TCGplayer’s market price, Card Kingdom’s retail price and Mana Pool’s lowest listing.

Elspeth's Nightmare Price Summary

The benchmark price (cheapest playable nonfoil) is $0.11, flat over 7 days, flat over 30 days, down 26.7% over 90 days.

Elspeth's Nightmare Price History

Markets TCGplayer marketreference

Markets on the chart

TCGplayer marketreference
Drag across the chart Tap or drag the chart
TCGplayer market
Card Kingdom retail
Card Kingdom buylist
Mana Pool, lowest listing
Cardmarket trend
TCGplayer change, 1 year
Low in range
High in range
Buylist spread
Markets shown

Elspeth's Nightmare price history chart, default range 3 months. currently $0.11.

Where to Buy and Sell Elspeth's Nightmare

Every market we track for PLST #THB-91 nonfoil on one line. The gray band is what you give up selling to a store instead of buying at market.

Elspeth's Nightmare in Sealed Products

Checking which sealed products hold PLST #THB-91 nonfoil.

Loading sealed products.

Elspeth's Nightmare Printings & Prices

Elspeth's Nightmare has 2 tracked printings across 2 sets, in nonfoil and foil finishes.

PLST set symbol, UncommonPLST #THB-91
Viewing
THB set symbol, UncommonTHB #91

Sell Elspeth's Nightmare: Buylist Offers

BuyerPrintingFinishCash offerMarketSpread to market
Card KingdomTHB #91Foil
CoolStuffIncTHB #91Foil
Card KingdomTHB #91Nonfoil
Card KingdomPLST #THB-91Nonfoil

Elspeth's Nightmare Rules Text & Legality

Elspeth's Nightmare

(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter. Sacrifice after III.)

I — Destroy target creature an opponent controls with power 2 or less.

II — Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. That player discards that card.

III — Exile target opponent's graveyard.

Elspeth's Nightmare is legal in Pioneer, Modern, Legacy and Commander, and not legal in Standard and Pauper.

View on Scryfall ↗

Elspeth's Nightmare Rulings

  • Jan 24, 2020

    A chapter ability doesn’t trigger if a lore counter is put on a Saga that already had a number of lore counters greater than or equal to that chapter’s number. For example, the third lore counter put on a Saga causes the III chapter ability to trigger, but I and II won’t trigger again.

  • Jan 24, 2020

    As a Saga enters the battlefield, its controller puts a lore counter on it. As your precombat main phase begins (immediately after your draw step), you put another lore counter on each Saga you control. Putting a lore counter on a Saga in either of these ways doesn’t use the stack.

  • Jan 24, 2020

    Each symbol on the left of a Saga’s text box represents a chapter ability. A chapter ability is a triggered ability that triggers when a lore counter that is put on the Saga causes the number of lore counters on the Saga to become equal to or greater than the ability’s chapter number. Chapter abilities are put onto the stack and may be responded to.

  • Jan 24, 2020

    If multiple chapter abilities trigger at the same time, their controller puts them on the stack in any order. If any of them require targets, those targets are chosen as you put the abilities on the stack, before any of those abilities resolve.

  • Jan 24, 2020

    Once a chapter ability has triggered, the ability on the stack won’t be affected if the Saga gains or loses counters, or if it leaves the battlefield.

Reprints & Reprint Risk

Elspeth's Nightmare has been reprinted 3 times.

  • Jan 24, 2020THB set symbol, UncommonTheros Beyond DeathTHB #91
  • Jan 24, 2020THB set symbol, UncommonTheros Beyond Death · foilTHB #91
  • Apr 29, 2022PLST set symbol, UncommonThe ListPLST #THB-91

Elspeth's Nightmare in Commander

Elspeth's Nightmare is the #12,412 most-played card on EDHREC, down 185 places over the last 30 days.

#12,412 EDHREC rank
across all Commander decks Down 185 in 30 days

Elspeth's Nightmare FAQ

How much is Elspeth's Nightmare worth?

Elspeth's Nightmare is worth about $0.11 for its cheapest playable printing as of Nov 9, 2026.

Is Elspeth's Nightmare legal in Commander?

Yes. Elspeth's Nightmare is legal in Commander. It is also legal in Pioneer, Modern and Legacy.

Has Elspeth's Nightmare been reprinted?

Yes. Elspeth's Nightmare has been reprinted 3 times, with 2 printings tracked on The Index.

Why is Elspeth's Nightmare cheap?

Elspeth's Nightmare trades at about $0.11; 3 reprints keep supply plentiful, and Commander demand is modest (#12,412 on EDHREC).