Magic
Guide Modern Horizons 3 Commander

Kaalia of the Vast Commander Guide: Best Cards for Your Deck

She is a doorman for eight-drops, and the whole table wants her dead. Build around keeping her alive.

20 min read

This article has affiliate links. TCG Strat may earn a commission when you buy through them. How we make money

Kaalia of the Vast Commander Guide: Best Cards for Your Deck

Blightsteel Colossus, Double Masters. Art by Wayne Reynolds.

Double Masters in the Index

The short version

5 points

Kaalia of the Vast is a four-mana 2/2 flier from 2011, and by herself she does nothing. Read the card again. She has flying, a single ability that fires when she attacks, and the temperament of a very polite doorman who will let an eight-mana Angel into the club once someone walks her to the door.

Everyone at the table knows this by turn three, which is why the doorman gets shot in the parking lot. So the deck is not really about cheating in Gisela, Blade of Goldnight. It is about whether a 2/2 survives long enough to hold the door open. The "latest and greatest" angle needs some honesty of its own. The commander is fifteen years old, the Angel, Demon, and Dragon pool refills every few sets, and several of the shiny arrivals cost eight or nine mana. They only make the list because she skips the bill.

Gisela, Blade of Goldnight
Gisela, Blade of GoldnightAVR set symbol, MythicAVR #209 · Mythic
Price history in the Index

Who Is Kaalia of the Vast?

"Puts a seven-drop into play on turn four" sounds busted. The catch is a list of things she does not do. She has no haste, no protection, no card draw, and the creature has to already be in hand. She also needs a turn cycle, which is a long time to be a legendary creature with a target on her.

The trigger works on attack declaration. If she gets blocked or dies in combat after attackers are declared, the creature still arrives, because the trigger is already on the stack. That makes her a much better deal than her fragility suggests. It only works against an opponent, not a planeswalker.

The Mardu identity (red, white, black) hands you Angels, Demons, and Dragons, which is where most of the format's oversized fliers live. She led the Heavenly Inferno precon in 2011 and she is among the most-brewed commanders in the format. That is the real problem for a writer. Differentiation lives entirely in the flex slots: your haste package, your protection, and which of the fifty-odd legal fatties make your 26 threat slots. Those are the choices this guide is about.

Kaalia of the Vast
Kaalia of the VastMH3 set symbol, MythicMH3 #290 · Mythic
Price history in the Index

The Plan: Land Kaalia, Cheat a Monster, Repeat Until Someone Cries

Early game, you ramp and assemble a hand of oversized fliers plus one piece of haste or protection. Turns three to five, Kaalia attacks and a free Angel, Demon, or Dragon lands tapped and attacking. Late game, the table either answers her over and over or loses to a board that cost you nothing.

You win by connecting with huge fliers, and damage doublers or extra-combat multipliers turn that from a threat into a kill. A typical win window in a Bracket 3 or 4 pod is turns five through eight, and it only comes that fast if nobody at the table is holding an answer.

Be honest about what this is. It is feast or famine. A hand of three seven-drops with no haste and no protection is a very expensive paperweight. I have watched Kaalia eat removal on turn four three games running, and each time the table looked relieved, like they had put out a small kitchen fire.

Some pods will kill her four or more times, so bring a plan that works on recast. Cheap ramp and a hardcastable threat base keep you moving when she is gone. The card engine matters most, since it has to work without her.

Then there is the social side. Drop Gisela, Blade of Goldnight on turn three and you are the archenemy before she has even finished dealing damage. Say sorry early. Say it warmly.

Haste and Protection: Keeping the Doorman Alive

Eight slots in the 99 go to this job: Lightning Greaves, Swiftfoot Boots, Lavaspur Boots, Deflecting Swat, Flawless Maneuver, Teferi's Protection, Earnest Fellowship, and Samut, Hazoret's Champion. Hall of the Bandit Lord counts as a land. It sits in the mana base and not here.

Greaves is the best of the equipment. Equip {0} gives Kaalia haste and shroud, so she attacks the turn she lands and the only window for removal is a response to the equip. Boots gives hexproof and haste but costs {1} to equip. That is fine, but it is a mana you wanted for something else. Lavaspur Boots is the cheap third sibling with ward {1} and haste, and it wants a tax-light table to matter.

Swat and Flawless Maneuver cost nothing only if you control a commander, so they are dead weight the turn after Kaalia dies. Swat is the priciest card in the package at about $75, and it can redirect removal onto something your opponent owns. Maneuver makes your whole team indestructible, so it beats damage and destroy effects but not exile. Teferi's Protection phases your whole board out, so it also beats a sweeper. It sits there like a fire extinguisher bolted to a wall. You hope nobody asks.

Earnest Fellowship is the budget tech. Each creature has protection from its own colors, so Kaalia shrugs off targeted red, white, and black removal, plus any red, white, or black blocker. Blue and green removal still gets through, and the enchantment is symmetrical, so opposing creatures get that protection too. Red sweepers like Blasphemous Act bounce off Kaalia as well. It costs about $1.55.

The counter-view is real. Too many protection slots dilute threat density, and recasting Kaalia as bait is a legitimate plan. I still say eight is right. A deck that wins by cheating needs the cheater to survive, and every slot that sits dead in your hand is a slot that would have been a fourth fatty sitting just as dead.

Lightning Greaves
Lightning GreavesTRC set symbol, UncommonTRC #496 · Uncommon
Price history in the Index

Draw Engines and Tutors: Fixing Feast or Famine

The deck runs eight card-draw and engine slots plus four tutor and reanimation slots. This section is about those twelve cards, because they are what turn a hand of nothing into a turn.

Kaalia, Zenith Seeker is the best engine in the deck. She is a commander in her own right, but as a three-mana 99th card she digs six deep and can hand you an Angel, a Demon, and a Dragon from a single cast. That fixes the "no fatty in hand" half of feast or famine, and her 3/3 flying vigilance body is good enough to attack. Pair her with Teleportation Circle and she re-digs every end step. Circle will also re-run Rune-Scarred Demon if you have one.

Demonic Counsel finds a Demon for two mana. With four or more card types in your graveyard, delirium makes it a second Demonic Tutor. A creature and an instant from your protection suite get you most of the way. Reanimate adds the sorcery type. Animate Dead mostly will not, since the Aura stays on the battlefield. Both also pull a creature card out of the graveyard, so count carefully.

Demonic Tutor fetches your haste piece or the exact fatty you need. It counts against the Bracket 3 limit of three, and Teferi's Protection counts too, so that allowance disappears fast. Budget builds skip it at $65.69.

Bitter Reunion is the cheap enchantment filter. Discard a dead seven-drop and draw two. Later, sacrifice it to give your team haste. For about seventy cents it is the best-value card in the deck.

Kaalia, Zenith Seeker
Kaalia, Zenith SeekerM20 set symbol, MythicM20 #210 · Mythic
Price history in the Index

Your Win Conditions: The Big Fliers Worth Cheating In

About 26 slots go to Angel, Demon, and Dragon threats. Keep the curve skewed low enough that you can hardcast some of them, or the first removal on Kaalia ends your game.

First, the damage doublers and pingers. Gisela, Blade of Goldnight is a seven-drop 5/5 flying first striker that doubles damage to your opponents and halves it to you. Pair it with Twinflame Tyrant, a five-mana Dragon that doubles damage to opponents as well, and the two stack. Terror of the Peaks pings for the power of every other creature you control that enters, so each big body Kaalia puts onto the battlefield after it shoots something. Its life-tax on spells that target it protects the card, not you.

Second, the extra-combat multiplier. Hardcast Aurelia, the Warleader rather than cheating her in. She has haste, so six mana gets her swinging with Kaalia. She untaps your team and gives you a second combat, so Kaalia triggers twice, and that means two free creatures. If Kaalia puts her onto the battlefield instead, the extra combat never happens, because she never attacked.

Third, the closers. Balefire Dragon wipes a board off one clean hit: when it connects, it deals that much damage to every creature that player controls.

Master of Cruelties is the card I would cut from every list. Cheated in by Kaalia, it still triggers if nobody blocks it, but it assigns no combat damage, so you spent your free drop on a card that leaves a player at 1 life and needs something else to finish the job. Hardcast, it has to attack alone, which means Kaalia sits out. Lists put it first because the text looks scary.

The New Toys: Latest Cards and Honest Reviews

Here is the honest accounting. Three cards lead the recent crop, and one of them is more of a hardcast card than a cheat target.

Avacyn, Angel of Horror costs eight, with three black pips. That is a cast cost you will never pay, which is fine because Kaalia ignores it. Once she is down, she returns herself and any other nontoken creature you control that dies, at the next end step. That includes Kaalia. A doorman who gets back up after being shot is a very different doorman. People sneer at the mana value, but she is fine.

Of the three, Curse-Marred Demon is the only one you want to hardcast. It is a four-mana 4/4 flying trampler that tutors any card, then discards one at random. That random discard can pitch the very card you fetched, so cast it when you are nearly empty-handed. It is also a fine reanimation target when it gets discarded.

Double damage for any creature you control that entered this turn: that is the whole pitch of Neriv, Heart of the Storm, a four-mana Mardu Dragon, and everything Kaalia cheats in hits twice as hard. Drakuseth, Maw of Flames comes in swinging for 7, which Neriv makes 14. If Neriv has haste via Greaves, he hits for 8 himself. Stack it with Gisela and the numbers get silly.

A few other post-2011 additions deserve a mention. In Mardu mode, Windcrag Siege doubles Kaalia's trigger for three mana. Smaug the Magnificent is a four-mana Dragon with haste that makes a Treasure each upkeep, and you hardcast it.

Avacyn, Angel of Horror
Avacyn, Angel of HorrorFRC set symbol, RareFRC #7 · Rare
Price history in the Index

Extra Combats and Trigger Copying: The Combo Lines to Know

This is an optional package, not a requirement. Every extra combat means Kaalia attacks again, and every attack puts one more free creature in. The ceiling is how many creature cards you're holding.

Aurelia, the Warleader is the baseline. Aggravated Assault untaps your team and adds a combat for {3}{R}{R}, repeatable. Full Throttle, a sorcery, gives two extra combats and untaps your attackers at the start of each, so Kaalia gets three attacks in a turn. Seize the Day untaps one creature, and flashback lets you do it twice. Bloodthirster adds a combat when it connects and untaps itself, but it can't hit the same player twice. Kaalia stays tapped, so she needs one of the untap effects above to trigger again.

Trigger copying works on a different axis. Strionic Resonator copies Kaalia's trigger for {2}, no extra combat needed. Windcrag Siege in Mardu mode and Isshin, Two Heavens as One both make an attacking creature's triggers fire an additional time. Siege is an enchantment, so it survives the removal that kills Isshin.

This package burns through cards fast. Three free creatures in a turn is a lot of cheat for a four-card hand, so it pairs with the draw engines above. If your pod has already killed Kaalia twice by turn six, skip it.

Aurelia, the Warleader
Aurelia, the WarleaderMAR set symbol, MythicMAR #86 · Mythic
Price history in the Index

How to Build It: Competitive vs. Casual

The base 99 splits like this: 36 lands, 9 ramp, 8 card-draw and engine pieces, 6 spot removal, 2 board wipes, 8 haste and protection slots, 4 tutors and reanimation, and 26 Angel, Demon, and Dragon threats. That adds up to 99. Aim for an average mana value around 3.5, with the expensive threats offset by ramp and the haste package.

The standard build is "big fliers plus protection," and it sits comfortably at casual through Bracket 3. It is the one to start with. Everything else is a variant of this 99, not an addition to it.

The extra-combats variant swaps about six threats and removal pieces for Aggravated Assault, Full Throttle, Seize the Day, Strionic Resonator, and friends. It is faster and more brittle, and it wants tutors more.

The reanimator hybrid swaps about four threats for Reanimate, Animate Dead, Karmic Guide, and Angel of the Ruins, whose plainscycling also fixes your mana. It is insurance against Kaalia removal, because the plan no longer lives or dies on her.

On budget, Earnest Fellowship, Bitter Reunion, and the equipment are all cheap. Skip Demonic Tutor, Deflecting Swat, and Teferi's Protection, and keep the mana base on basics.

Because she cheats three tribes, you can swap between Angel, Demon, and Dragon packages game to game. Keep the core and rotate the threats.

Aggravated Assault
Aggravated AssaultWOT set symbol, RareWOT #39 · Rare
Price history in the Index

The Verdict: Is Kaalia of the Vast Worth Building?

Yes, if you like big dumb fliers, explosive turns, and being the table's first target. Skip her if you hate being the archenemy or lose patience when your commander dies for the third time. The ceiling is a free bomb on turn three to five. The floor is a hand of uncastable Angels and a dead 2/2.

The shiny new cards are not what makes the deck work. Protection is. Eight slots of it, plus a card engine that does not rely on her, and a plan that works on recast.

The one card I would cut from every list is Master of Cruelties. The one card people overreact to is Avacyn, Angel of Horror, who is fine. And here is the take you might dislike: Kaalia is a doorman, not a win condition. The best Kaalia deck is the one that keeps her alive, or the one that does not need her.

Doorman, always.

Master of Cruelties
Master of CrueltiesRVR set symbol, MythicRVR #373 · Mythic
Price history in the Index

Every card in this article

Nonfoil unless noted. The dot marks the lowest US price for each card.

Open in the Index